Contact AUD      Contribute to AUD      About AUD       Sign up for updates     Site index     Search this website     Request help

Home Legal Rights Education Union Democracy Review Books


Union Democracy Review -- selected articles

Previous Article: Matt Noyes on AUD and the Internet

Next Article: If you can't woo 'em, sue 'em! An ingenious twist in punishing dissent in the SEIU

AUDHome--> Union Democracy Review--> Articles

Teamsters, get all the union democracy news: SUBSCRIBE to Union Democracy Review!

From the March-April 2005 issue of Union Democracy Review #155

Harvey for TDU charges Teamster IRB coddles top Hoffa aide

Carlos Scalf, executive assistant to Teamster President Jimmy Hoffa, was found guilty by the Independent Review Board of misappropriating over $69,000 from the union. The IRB made him return the money and suspended him briefly from all union positions. Oddly enough, however, he was allowed to retain his union membership in good standing. Others have been expelled for life for less. In a letter to the presiding judge on behalf of the Teamsters for a Democratic Union, attorney Barbara Harvey protested against what she charges is kid-glove treatment. Before the subject reached the judge, Hoffa fired Scalf. Short excerpts from Attorney Harvey's letter follow.

"...Without explicit acknowledgment, the settlement appears to be based on the premise that Scalf's repayment of all or at least a substantial portion of the sum that he wrongfully accepted justifies a "slap on the wrist" penalty of a 60-day unpaid suspension... Lesser union officials have gone to federal prison and been barred from all union positions for the 13-year period mandated by the LMRDA, section 502 for [offenses] such as Mr. Scalf has clearly committed without confessing them in the agreement. ...The Consent Decree under which the agreement has been submitted for Court approval provides an independent body of precedent showing penalties that are far harsher than those mandated by LMRDA section 502, including lifetime bans from union office, membership, and association with other Teamster members...
In April 2004, former RISE administrator Edwin Stier accused Scalf of interfering with his investigation into possible connections between the Chicago Mafia and Chicago Teamster locals. Stier reported the Scalf's interference forced him to terminate his investigation...

"[The New York Times reported] "In 2001, the IRB forced Richard Lyder, executive assistant to the union's secretary treasurer, to resign after it found that he had taken $3,400 in unauthorized meal expenses. He was barred from future dealings with the union." ...the IRB's standing as an institution having membership trust may be irreparably injured unless this application is supported by a factual record, presently absent, showing that Scalf's misconduct warrants the "slap on the wrist" that he has received, rather than the penalties required by the LMRDA and historically imposed under the Consent Decree when a high-level union fiduciary engages in... breaches involving fraudulent self-dealing and embezzlement of union funds."

Articles on the Teamsters:
In the Teamsters Union: What's the dollar cost of cruel beatings?
At the Teamsters Independent Review Board (3/08-4/08)
Teamster elections: inspiration from the ground up (11/06-12/06)
AUD Conference: Confronting Corruption in Labor Unions (12-06)
Teamster Convention reveals fatal flaw in election rules (7/06-8/06)
Harvey for TDU charges IRB coddles top Hoffa aide (3/05-4/05)
RISE uncovers corruption before its demise (9/04-10/04)
RISE and Teamster reform at Cornell University
Can the IBT police itself?(9/03-10/03)
The Transmogrification of Teamsters Local 854(9/03-10/03)
Is Teamsters Union safe for dissenters? An exchange (10/11 2002)
The vindication of Ron Carey (12/1 2001-2002)
"The Fox and the Chicken Coop" -- comments on the proposed Teamsters Ethics Code. (3/4 2000)
"Some Modest Proposals for a Teamster Code" (3/4 2000)

back to top

Previous Article: Matt Noyes on AUD and the Internet

Next Article: If you can't woo 'em, sue 'em! An ingenious twist in punishing dissent in the SEIU

This website is made possible by contributions from union members and supporters like you. Please help us build the movement for union democracy, join or contribute to AUD.

AUDHome; Legal Rights; Education; Union Democracy Review; Books; AUDLinks

Page designed by Matt Noyes, National Writers Union/UAW, and Rachel Szekely
The Association for Union Democracy.
104 Montgomery Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11225; USA; 718-564-1114;

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons License.

Use the following credit line on the materials you use:
"From the website of the Association for Union Democracy. Email: 104 Montgomery Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11225; USA; 718-564-1114"

Please notify us at when you use material from the site.

Send comments or suggestions on the website to