Tell a friend about this article
Previous Article: Blocking Carpenters move for more bureaucratic power
Next Article: On the eve of elections in Musicians Local 802
AUDHome--> Union Democracy Review--> Articles
SUBSCRIBE to Union Democracy Review!
From the September-October 2006 issue of Union Democracy Review #164
Round 2 in the internet battle in AFSCME DC37
On September 12th, the AFSCME Judicial Panel issued its decision in a case involving rank-and-file use of the internet. Cody Childs, secretary of AFSCME Local 2627, in New York City's DC37, was the only member of his opposition slate to win in a fall 2005 rerun election. No complaint was ever filed challenging his election; but several months later, the local executive board demanded that he reimburse the local for $2,400 in lawyer's fees that it claimed were incurred because of his website use around the time of the election. The local president had retained the lawyer to charge Childs with misrepresenting his own websites as the official local site. At a local meeting, the membership rejected the board recommendation and instead voted to require the E-Board members who voted to assess Childs to come up with the money! In May, charges were filed against Childs with the AFSCME Judicial Panel. The complainant asked that Childs be suspended from the union for three years and be ordered to reimburse the local for its related costs, including the $2,400 it paid a lawyer to tell him to cease and desist.
In its decision, the one-man panel held that Childs was prohibited by the AFSCME constitution from maintaining, without the local's authorization, websites registered to him --- "local 2627.us", "local 2627.info", and "local 2627.net---- and from using Local2627@aol.com as an email address, arguing that members could have confused Childs's sites with the local's. The panel concluded, however, that a name that included an identification of the addressee as a member or group of members-- for examples, "local2627member" or "Local 2627 members for a better union"-- would have been acceptable as an email address. Further, the panel officer said, Childs's homepage was so similar to the local's that it was apparently intended to deceive the membership and affect the outcome of the election.
The panel hearing officer did acknowledge that corrective modifications were made by Childs immediately upon the threat of legal action, including a disclaimer that his site was unofficial and independent of the local; but the officer concluded that much of its design and content remained the same, thus requiring redesign of the local's site. He ordered that Childs be formally reprimanded and warned against repetition. He ordered Childs to make restitution to the local for both legal costs of $2,400 and the cost of the local's website redesign (which the local claims was some $650) and also ordered that he cease using the website names and email address.
Childs replies that he has the right to choose his own site names; but he has changed them to accommodate the panel's concerns. Further, he says that he changed the website within hours after a simple phone message from the attorney. Had any elected local officials called him, the result would have been the same. It was unnecessary, and their choice, he argues, to bring in an expensive attorney . In any event, the fees are completely disproportionate in the circumstances. Moreover, he adds, the local president was never properly authorized to retain an outside attorney.
Childs also replies that after he altered his site, no one could have reasonably confused it with the official union site. Therefore, he claims, because redesign of the union website was unnecessary, the costs should not be shifted to him.
Arguing that the trial officer denied him an opportunity to present evidence on these points and failed to properly consider the evidence that was presented, Childs has appealed the decision to the full AFCME judicial panel.
Articles
on the internet and union democracy:
Surrendering
to the internet: Democrats in spite of themselves?
IBEW
president Hill upholds Canadian member's rights
Union
officials "condone and endorse" attack on member's internet free speech
rights
Round
2 in the internet battle in AFSCME DC37
In AFSCME
DC37 - A round in the internet battle
Danger of democracy on the Internet? Kill it!
Whose
"IBEW" is it? An Electrician on the Internet.
Results
of the 2005 AUD Best Rank-and-File Website Contest
Union
democracy online survives two lawsuits
Online
Guide: build an effective rank-and-file website
SEIU
Pulls plug on "Labor's Future" discussion
52
Playing cards = fearsome "Local 52"
Using the Internet for Union Democracy
AUD's Best Rank-and-File Websites of 2004
Matt
Noyes on AUD and the Internet
2KB
of free speech? ACLU & Public Citizen sue in IBEW Local 46 election
Making a splash:
SEIU's Unite to Win and the "free and open debate" on Labor's future
SAG officers unnerved by actors' internet free speech
Free speech irritates UFCW
Free speech in NWU
IATSE 600: Internet
democracy triumphs over super centralization
Cyber-democracy:
your legal rights online.(handout)
See
also:
AUD's 50 Guidelines for
building an effective rank-and-file website, and the sample
homepage.
The labortech tag
on del.icio.us.
Previous Article: Blocking Carpenters move for more bureaucratic power
Next Article: On the eve of elections in Musicians Local 802
This website is made possible by contributions from union members and supporters like you. Please help us build the movement for union democracy, join or contribute to AUD.
AUDHome; Legal Rights; Education; Union Democracy Review; Books; AUDLinks
Page designed by Matt Noyes, National
Writers Union/UAW, and Rachel Szekely
The Association for Union Democracy. www.uniondemocracy.org
104 Montgomery Street, Brooklyn,
New York, 11225; USA; 718-564-1114; info@uniondemocracy.org
This work is licensed
under a Creative
Commons License.
Use
the following credit line on the materials you use:
"From the
website of the Association for Union Democracy. www.uniondemocracy.org. Email:
info@uniondemocracy.org. 104 Montgomery Street, Brooklyn, New York, 11225; USA;
718-564-1114"
Please notify us at websteward@uniondemocracy.org when you use material from the site.
Send comments or suggestions on the website to websteward@uniondemocracy.org.